I never knew a drummer could make so much difference.
But ever since Bill Berry left R.E.M. in 1997 to pursue uh, farming, R.E.M. has been going through the motions, making albums as if they were punching their time card at a factory. 1998’s Up yielded only one memorable song, and Reveal and Around the Sun were instantly forgettable.
It’s been a shocker – R.E.M., the trailblazing godfathers of college rock, has been forgotten. Kids entering their teen years have not seen a great R.E.M. album in their lifetime. That shouldn’t be allowed.
Accelerate, the band’s 14th album, doesn’t rank among their greatest, but it is a step in the right direction. The band has finally begun listening to critics and fans and remembered the formula for their success – a raw, energetic sound that hasn’t been heard since 1986′ Lifes Rich Pageant. They rock. Finally.
The opening number, “Living Well is the Best Revenge,” tumbles through with a helter-skelter pace that leaves you breathless. “Man-Sized Wreath” is also powerful, but with a more pop-oriented sound akin to Green‘s “Pop Song ’89.” And the first single, “Supernatural Superserious,” is a vintage, albeit safe number accented by what has become Peter Buck’s new trademark: a distorted, staccato-tinged guitar riff.
I said it’s a step in the right direction. But the middle of the album finds the band moving more toward the safer, adult-alternative route that worked for them during Out of Time and Automatic for the People, but now sounds downright boring. It’s only during the final numbers, “Horse to Water” and “I’m Gonna DJ,” that the band finds its sound again. It’s a sound of R.E.M. past.
And I’ve missed that. I’m glad to see their familiar faces again.